Are Marshmallows Halal?

By
Are Marshmallows Halal? cover with real Lucky Charms, Jet-Puffed, PEEPS, Rice Krispies Treats and MoonPie packages on a warm yellow Halal Watch background
On this page
  1. History of the Product
  2. Ingredients of the Product
  3. Each Ingredient Broken Down
  4. The Gelatin Question
  5. What the Companies Say Publicly
  6. How It Is Manufactured
  7. Other Marshmallow Products
  8. The Religious Basis
  9. How We Graded
  10. Frequently Asked Questions
  11. Final Verdict – Marshmallows
  12. Credits
  13. Sources

Short answer: Almost never, if the marshmallow is made with gelatin. Halal Watch World checked the big U.S. marshmallow brands, the store brands, and the cereals, snacks, cocoa and ice cream that have marshmallows in them. Nearly every one fails the Halal Watch standard because of its gelatin. Kraft Heinz (Jet-Puffed), Campfire, Just Born (PEEPS), General Mills (Lucky Charms) and the maker of MoonPie say their gelatin comes from pork. Kellanova (Rice Krispies Treats) and Swiss Miss say theirs may be beef or pork, and most store brands do not say which animal theirs comes from. One product passes: Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows, a seasonal marshmallow made without gelatin. The other gelatin-free products we could grade, and Elyon's fish-gelatin marshmallows, are graded doubtful because the source of their flavor is not disclosed, and we advise refraining from them.

Grade: FAIL for Jet-Puffed, Campfire, PEEPS, Lucky Charms, Rice Krispies Treats, MoonPie, Swiss Miss marshmallow cocoa and every other gelatin product in this report. PASS for Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows.

DOUBTFUL for Trader Joe's regular marshmallows, Dandies, Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme, Marshmallow Fluff and the other gelatin-free products in this report, and for Elyon (made with fish gelatin), because the source of their flavorings is not disclosed. We advise refraining from them.

Marshmallows are a fixture of American campfires, hot cocoa and holiday baking, and they turn up in far more than the bag. They are in breakfast cereals, snack cakes, cookies, cereal bars, cocoa mixes and ice cream. None of these foods contain meat, so it is easy to assume they are halal. For a halal-conscious consumer, one ingredient usually decides the answer: gelatin. For this report, Halal Watch World reviewed the U.S. labels and public statements for more than 100 marshmallow products from the biggest names on the shelf, hoping to find some that Muslim families can enjoy.

A close-up of plain white marshmallows
Plain white marshmallows. Photo: John Morgan, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

History of the Product

The marshmallow takes its name from a plant. The National Confectioners Association explains that the original treat was made from the mallow plant, which grows wild in marshes, and that ancient Egyptians enjoyed it "as early as 2000 BC." Delaware's Division of Historical and Cultural Affairs adds that the earliest known recipe, from Egypt around 2000 B.C.E., "was not used as a tasty snack, but as medicine instead."

The marshmallow became a candy in France. According to the National Confectioners Association, in the early to mid-1800s, "Owners of small candy stores whipped sap from the mallow root into a fluffy candy mold." Later in the century, candy makers began casting marshmallows in starch molds, and at the same time they "replaced the mallow root with gelatin." Delaware's historians describe the same change: "During the 1800s, marshmallow lozenges (as they were known at the time) became gelatin-based, ultimately eliminating the use of the plant that its name is derived from." The plant that gave the candy its name was replaced by an animal ingredient well over a century ago.

In the United States, Campfire Marshmallows have been sold since 1917, when, according to the company, "the Imperial Candy Co./Redel Candy Corp. of Milwaukee introduced the delicious treats, with packaging that recommended roasting the product over fires." The National Confectioners Association traces the s'more to the 1927 Girl Scout Handbook. Campfire also says that in 1939, Mildred Day and Malitta Jensen of the Campfire Girls used its marshmallows "to create the first Rice Krispies marshmallow treat as part of a fundraiser for the Michigan Campfire Girls council."

An early Campfire Marshmallows advertising card showing desserts made with marshmallows
An early Campfire Marshmallows advertising card from The Campfire Co. of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, offering a dessert recipe book. Image: The Campfire Co., public domain, via Digital Commonwealth and Wikimedia Commons.

The modern factory marshmallow comes from the Doumak family. Doumak, Inc. says it began making cast mold marshmallows in Los Angeles in 1921. Alex Doumak later developed extrusion, a process in which, as Campfire describes it, "the marshmallow mixture is pressed through tubes, then cut into equal pieces, cooled and packaged." Sources date his invention differently: Campfire and the National Confectioners Association give 1948, and Doumak's website gives 1954. The U.S. patent, No. 2,847,311, was filed by Alexander J. Doumak of Los Angeles and James Doumak in April 1956 and granted in August 1958. Campfire itself now belongs to the same company: "Since 2003, Campfire Marshmallows has been part of the Doumak, Inc. family of brands, with headquarters based in Illinois."

Kraft entered the market soon after. The New York Times Magazine reported in 2012 that "Kraft began extruding its own marshmallows in the late 1950s," and that its most creative touch might have been "the space-age name it gave to the factory process," jet-puffed. Kraft Heinz still describes Jet-Puffed as "America's favorite space-age marshmallow since 1959." According to the Indianapolis Business Journal, Kraft began making caramels in Kendallville, Indiana, in 1935, and the plant there "began making Jet-Puffed products in 1961." The National Confectioners Association says Americans buy more than 90 million pounds of marshmallows a year.

Marshmallow snacks are nearly as old as the bagged marshmallow. Nabisco sold its first Mallomars to a grocer in Hoboken, New Jersey, on November 13, 1913, according to Food Dive, and Mallomars are still sold only from September to March. Chattanooga Bakery, founded in Tennessee in 1902, says of MoonPie: "It all began in 1917 when a KY coal miner asked our traveling salesman for a snack 'as big as the moon.'" Marshmallow Fluff dates from the same years: its maker says that before World War I, Archibald Query of Somerville, Massachusetts, made it in his kitchen and sold it door to door, and that after wartime shortages closed his business, Durkee and Mower "pooled their saving and bought it for five hundred dollars." The Battle Creek Enquirer reports that the recipe now known as Rice Krispies Treats "appeared on packages in 1940," and that Kellogg's launched its packaged bars in 1995. Business Insider reports that the Hostess Sno Ball was introduced in 1947 and did not get its creme filling or its pink color until 1950.

Two of the best-known marshmallow candies came later. Just Born acquired the Rodda Candy Company of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, in 1953, when Rodda's popular marshmallow chick "was made by laboriously hand-squeezing marshmallow through pastry tubes." The company mechanized the process, and today, it says, "what once took 27 hours to produce and package, the iconic PEEPS® Chick now only takes 6 minutes." General Mills says Lucky Charms "made its magical debut in 1964," after product developer John Holahan mixed chopped-up pieces of his favorite candy, Circus Peanuts, with Cheerios. Since 2020, the marshmallows have also been sold on their own in stores as Lucky Charms Just Magical Marshmallows. Stuffed Puffs released its chocolate-filled marshmallow in 2019.

Ingredients of the Product

Most marshmallows in this report are made from the same short recipe. This is the current U.S. ingredient list for Jet-Puffed Marshmallows (12 oz, 1 lb and 24 oz bags), exactly as Kraft Heinz publishes it:

CORN SYRUP, SUGAR, DEXTROSE, MODIFIED CORNSTARCH, WATER, CONTAINS LESS THAN 2% OF GELATIN, TETRASODIUM PYROPHOSPHATE (WHIPPING AID), NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, BLUE 1.

Source: kraftheinz.com, Jet-Puffed Marshmallows, accessed November 15, 2026.

Kraft Heinz product page for Jet-Puffed Marshmallows showing the ingredient list, from corn syrup, sugar and dextrose to gelatin, natural and artificial flavor and Blue 1.
The current U.S. ingredient list for Jet-Puffed Marshmallows on Kraft Heinz's product page. Screenshot of https://www.kraftheinz.com/jet-puffed/products/00600699003285-marshmallows, captured November 16, 2026.

Campfire Regular Marshmallows list almost the same ingredients, without the blue color: "CORN SYRUP, SUGAR, MODIFIED FOOD STARCH (CORN), GELATIN, WATER, DEXTROSE, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, TETRASODIUM PYROPHOSPHATE." So do most store brands. Target's Good & Gather Marshmallows go one step further and name the animal on the label: "corn syrup, sugar, modified corn starch, gelatin (pork), water, dextrose, natural flavors, tetrasodium pyrophosphate." Kraft Heinz says the package is the final word. Answering a shopper on Target.com, the Kraft Heinz Team wrote: "Formulas may change and the best source of information is the list of ingredients on the package."

Ingredient list for Good & Gather Marshmallows on Target.com, including the words gelatin (pork).
Target's listing for Good & Gather Marshmallows, 10 oz, names the animal: "gelatin (pork)." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/marshmallows-10oz-good-38-gather-8482/-/A-77640517, captured November 16, 2026.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on Target.com marked Brand expert: Formulas may change and the best source of information is the list of ingredients on the package.
The Kraft Heinz Team, answering a shopper on Target.com's Jet-Puffed Marshmallows page: "Formulas may change and the best source of information is the list of ingredients on the package." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/kraft-jet-puffed-marshmallows-10-oz/-/A-12968507?showOnlyQuestions=true, captured November 16, 2026.

The one product in this report that passes is made differently. This is the ingredient list for Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows (6 oz), as Trader Joe's publishes it:

TAPIOCA SYRUP, CANE SUGAR, WATER, TAPIOCA STARCH, CARRAGEENAN, SOY PROTEIN, VEGETABLE JUICE (COLOR), PEPPERMINT OIL. CONTAINS SOY.

Source: traderjoes.com, Peppermint Mini Marshmallows, accessed November 16, 2026. Trader Joe's lists the ingredients one per line; they are shown here separated by commas.

Trader Joe's describes this seasonal product, sold for a limited time, this way: "They're gluten free, gelatin free, vegan, and kosher (pareve), just like our other 'mallows." Its regular Marshmallows and Mini Marshmallows use the same base recipe, but with "NATURAL VANILLA FLAVOR" in place of the vegetable juice color and peppermint oil.

Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Marshmallows: tapioca syrup, cane sugar, water, tapioca starch, carrageenan, soy protein and natural vanilla flavor.
Trader Joe's Marshmallows: no gelatin, but "NATURAL VANILLA FLAVOR" of undisclosed source. Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/marshmallows-056661, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Mini Marshmallows ending with natural vanilla flavor; no gelatin is listed.
Trader Joe's Mini Marshmallows use the same recipe, including "NATURAL VANILLA FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/mini-marshmallows-057620, captured November 16, 2026.

Each Ingredient Broken Down

Halal Watch World keeps an ingredient database built from its own product reviews. The rulings below come from that database. Where the database has no ruling for an ingredient, the table says which Halal Watch World standard was applied instead.

Jet-Puffed Marshmallows (the typical gelatin marshmallow)

IngredientStatusSourceBasis
Corn syrupHalalPlantHalal Watch ingredient database: halal by default
SugarHalalPlantHalal Watch ingredient database: halal by default
DextroseHalalPlantHalal Watch ingredient database: halal by default
Modified cornstarchHalalPlantHalal Watch ingredient database: halal by default
WaterHalalMineralNo separate database record; halal by default (HIPS 1001 §1.4.1.1)
GelatinNot permissibleAnimal: pork-based, per Kraft HeinzHIPS 1001 §1.3.2(b) and HIPS 1003-A §8.6 (see below)
Tetrasodium pyrophosphate (whipping aid)HalalInorganic saltRelated pyrophosphate salts are halal in the Halal Watch ingredient database; no separate record; halal by default (HIPS 1001 §1.4.1.1)
Natural and artificial flavorMashbuh (doubtful)Not disclosedHalal Watch ingredient database: doubtful, "Unknown ingredients"
Blue 1HalalSyntheticHalal Watch ingredient database: halal when the color is pure dye. HIPS 1003-A: "Synthetic colorants and plant-derived colorants are acceptable on disclosure statement."

Seven of the nine ingredients are halal in our database or under Halal Watch World's standard. The flavor is marked doubtful because Kraft Heinz does not say what it is made of. The gelatin is what decides the answer.

Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows (the product that passes)

IngredientStatusSourceBasis
Tapioca syrupHalalPlant (cassava)No separate database record; a sugar syrup made from a plant starch, halal by default (HIPS 1001 §1.4.1.1, which names "sugar, most vegetation")
Cane sugarHalalPlantHalal Watch ingredient database: halal by default
WaterHalalMineralNo separate database record; halal by default (HIPS 1001 §1.4.1.1)
Tapioca starchHalalPlantHalal Watch ingredient database: halal by default
CarrageenanHalalSeaweedHalal Watch ingredient database: halal by default
Soy proteinHalalPlantHalal Watch ingredient database: halal by default
Vegetable juice (color)HalalPlantHIPS 1003-A: "Synthetic colorants and plant-derived colorants are acceptable on disclosure statement."
Peppermint oilHalalPlantHalal Watch ingredient database: natural peppermint flavor and peppermint leaf are halal by default. HIPS 1003-A §8.8: "Steam-distilled or cold-pressed essential oils from plant sources are acceptable on disclosure statement."

All eight ingredients are halal in our database or under Halal Watch World's standard. There is no gelatin and no other animal ingredient. In place of gelatin, the recipe uses carrageenan, a gelling agent made from seaweed, and soy protein. Peppermint oil is the plant's essential oil; Purdue University Extension explains that mint oil "is readily recovered by steam distillation of the harvested hay." Apart from the color, the only difference from Trader Joe's regular marshmallows is the flavoring, and that difference is why the regular ones are not graded in this report (see below).

The Gelatin Question

Gelatin is what turns whipped sugar into a marshmallow. The New York Times Magazine described the marshmallows of a century ago as "a froth of sugar, starch and gelatin," and the recipe is much the same today. The Gelatin Manufacturers Institute of America explains that gelatin "is widely used in confections because it foams, gels, or solidifies into a piece that dissolves slowly or melts in the mouth."

Excerpt from the GMIA Gelatin Handbook stating that gelatin is widely used in confections because it foams, gels, or solidifies into a piece that dissolves slowly or melts in the mouth.
Gelatin Manufacturers Institute of America: gelatin "is widely used in confections because it foams, gels, or solidifies into a piece that dissolves slowly or melts in the mouth." From Gelatin Manufacturers Institute of America, Gelatin Handbook (2012), PDF page 14, https://nitta-gelatin.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/GMIA_Gelatin-Handbook.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.

Gelatin is always an animal product. The institute's handbook states: "There are no plant sources of gelatin." It names the main raw materials as "cattle bones, cattle hides, and porkskins," and adds that "Porkskin is a significant raw material source for production of edible gelatin in the United States." Halal Watch World's ingredient standard treats gelatin as an animal ingredient even when nothing about the food looks animal, and gives "gelatin in a confectionery product" as its example (HIPS 1001 §2.6.2).

Excerpt from the GMIA Gelatin Handbook: There are no plant sources of gelatin.
GMIA Gelatin Handbook: "There are no plant sources of gelatin." From Gelatin Manufacturers Institute of America, Gelatin Handbook (2012), PDF page 4, https://nitta-gelatin.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/GMIA_Gelatin-Handbook.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.
Excerpt from the GMIA Gelatin Handbook naming the principal raw materials of gelatin as cattle bones, cattle hides, and porkskins.
GMIA Gelatin Handbook: the principal raw materials are "cattle bones, cattle hides, and porkskins." From Gelatin Manufacturers Institute of America, Gelatin Handbook (2012), PDF page 6, https://nitta-gelatin.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/GMIA_Gelatin-Handbook.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.
Excerpt from the GMIA Gelatin Handbook: Porkskin is a significant raw material source for production of edible gelatin in the United States.
GMIA Gelatin Handbook: "Porkskin is a significant raw material source for production of edible gelatin in the United States." From Gelatin Manufacturers Institute of America, Gelatin Handbook (2012), PDF page 6, https://nitta-gelatin.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/GMIA_Gelatin-Handbook.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.

Many of the companies in this report have said publicly which animal their gelatin comes from. This is what they say:

Company and productsWhat the company says about the gelatinWhere it says so
Kraft Heinz: Jet-Puffed"The type of gelatin used in JET-PUFFED Marshmallows are pork-based."Kraft Heinz Team answer to a shopper on Target.com
Doumak, Inc.: Campfire"Yes, our marshmallows are made with porcine gelatin (except when we produce with a special recipe for export to markets in the Middle East.)"Campfire FAQ
Just Born: PEEPS"The gelatin used in our marshmallow candies is derived from pork products."Just Born FAQ
General Mills: Lucky Charms and other cereals with marshmallow "marbits""The gelatin in our marshmallow marbit pieces is made from pork collagen."Ask General Mills
Chattanooga Bakery: MoonPie"We use porkskin gelatin."MoonPie FAQ
Target: Good & Gather Marshmallows and Mini Marshmallows"gelatin (pork)"Ingredient label
Trader Joe's: Snowflake Marshmallows, Crispy Rice Bars, Dark Chocolate Covered Marshmallows"PORK GELATIN"Ingredient labels
Kellanova: Rice Krispies Treats"Some of our foods contain gelatin that is derived from EITHER Beef or Pork; sourcing is based on availability in the marketplace."Kellanova U.S. FAQ
Conagra Brands: Swiss Miss"It is derived from collagen from beef and/or pork bones."Swiss Miss ingredient description on Conagra's SmartLabel page
Kellanova: frosted Pop-Tarts, including Frosted S'mores"Beef gelatin is used in Pop-Tarts® toaster pastries, bites, and crunchy poppers"Kellanova Away From Home letter, August 11, 2026
Target: Favorite Day Halloween Friends; Trees, Santa and Gingerbread Men"gelatin (bovine)"Ingredient labels
Trader Joe's: Strawberry & Watermelon Marshmallows"BOVINE GELATIN"Ingredient label
Little Debbie Marshmallow Pies and Easter Marshmallow Puffs; Aldi Specially Selected Peppermint Marshmallows"Kosher Gelatin," with no animal namedIngredient labels
Elyon"Kosher Fish Gelatin (from Nile Perch or Tilapia)"Ingredient label, as shown by U.S. retailers
Kroger, Great Value, Aldi Baker's Corner, 365 by Whole Foods Market, Stuffed Puffs, Malt-O-Meal and Post cereals, Mallomars, Pinwheels, Little Debbie Marshmallow Treat, Hostess Sno Balls and others"gelatin," with no animal namedIngredient labels

In their own words: what the companies say about their gelatin (screenshots captured November 16, 2026)

Shopper question Gelatin from which animal? Is there pork? and Kraft Heinz Team answer marked Brand expert: The type of gelatin used in JET-PUFFED Marshmallows are pork-based.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on Target.com's Jet-Puffed Marshmallows page: "The type of gelatin used in JET-PUFFED Marshmallows are pork-based." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/kraft-jet-puffed-marshmallows-10-oz/-/A-12968507?showOnlyQuestions=true, captured November 16, 2026.
Campfire Marshmallows FAQ question Are your marshmallows made with porcine gelatin? with the answer that they are, except for a special export recipe for the Middle East.
Campfire FAQ: "Yes, our marshmallows are made with porcine gelatin (except when we produce with a special recipe for export to markets in the Middle East.)" Screenshot of https://www.campfiremarshmallows.com/frequently-asked-questions/, captured November 16, 2026.
Just Born FAQ question What type of gelatin is in PEEPS with the answer: The gelatin used in our marshmallow candies is derived from pork products.
Just Born FAQ: "The gelatin used in our marshmallow candies is derived from pork products." Screenshot of https://www.justborn.com/faqs, captured November 16, 2026.
Ask General Mills answer stating that the gelatin in its marshmallow marbit pieces is made from pork collagen.
Ask General Mills: "The gelatin in our marshmallow marbit pieces is made from pork collagen." Screenshot of https://ask.generalmills.com/s/article/What-s-the-gelatin-in-your-marshmallow-pieces-marbits-made-from, captured November 16, 2026.
MoonPie FAQ question What type of gelatin is used in a MoonPie? with the answer: We use porkskin gelatin.
MoonPie FAQ: "We use porkskin gelatin." Screenshot of https://www.moonpie.com/about/contact/index.html, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Good & Gather Mini Marshmallows on Target.com, including gelatin (pork).
Target's listing for Good & Gather Mini Marshmallows, 10 oz: "gelatin (pork)." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/mini-marshmallows-10oz-good-38-gather-8482/-/A-77640518, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Snowflake Marshmallows including pork gelatin.
Trader Joe's Snowflake Marshmallows label: "PORK GELATIN." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/snowflake-marshmallows-084767, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Crispy Rice Bars including pork gelatin in the marshmallow.
Trader Joe's Crispy Rice Bars label: "PORK GELATIN." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/crispy-rice-bars-083604, captured November 16, 2026.
Kellanova U.S. FAQ answer on gelatin: it applies to products made for the United States market, lists beef gelatin for frosted Pop-Tarts and says all varieties of Rice Krispies Treats contain gelatin derived from either beef or pork.
Kellanova U.S. FAQ, "Gelatin - Products that contain": "Some of our foods contain gelatin that is derived from EITHER Beef or Pork; sourcing is based on availability in the marketplace." The list starts with "All varieties of Kellogg's® Rice Krispies Treats®". Frosted Pop-Tarts are listed under beef. Screenshot of https://kelloggconsumeraffairs.my.salesforce-sites.com/kwFAQKellogs?website=Kelloggs%20US, captured November 16, 2026.
Swiss Miss SmartLabel ingredient description: gelatin is derived from collagen from beef and/or pork bones.
Conagra's SmartLabel page for Swiss Miss Marshmallow Lovers: the gelatin "is derived from collagen from beef and/or pork bones." Screenshot of https://smartlabel.conagra.com/070920476599-0003-en-US/index.html, captured November 16, 2026.
Heading of a Kellanova Away From Home letter dated August 11, 2026, to US customers, subject Gelatin in Kellanova Away From Home Products.
Kellanova Away From Home letter, "Gelatin in Kellanova Away From Home Products," dated August 11, 2026. From Kellanova Away From Home, "Gelatin in Kellanova Away From Home Products," letter dated August 11, 2026, PDF page 1, https://www.kellanovaawayfromhome.com/content/dam/NorthAmerica/awayfromhome-snacks/resources/k12/2026-nutrition-letters/Kellanova_Gelatin_Letter_8-11-2026-US_ONLY.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.
Kellanova letter text for US products naming beef gelatin in Pop-Tarts toaster pastries, bites and crunchy poppers and beef or pork gelatin in Rice Krispies Treats bars.
The same letter, "For our US products": beef gelatin in Pop-Tarts toaster pastries, bites and crunchy poppers, and beef or pork gelatin in Rice Krispies Treats bars. From Kellanova Away From Home, "Gelatin in Kellanova Away From Home Products," letter dated August 11, 2026, PDF page 1, https://www.kellanovaawayfromhome.com/content/dam/NorthAmerica/awayfromhome-snacks/resources/k12/2026-nutrition-letters/Kellanova_Gelatin_Letter_8-11-2026-US_ONLY.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Favorite Day Halloween Friends Marshmallows on Target.com including gelatin (bovine).
Target's listing for Favorite Day Halloween Friends Marshmallows: "gelatin (bovine)." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/halloween-friends-marshmallows-6-35oz-12ct-favorite-day-8482/-/A-95050913, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Favorite Day Trees, Santa and Gingerbread Men Marshmallows on Target.com including gelatin (bovine).
Target's listing for Favorite Day Trees, Santa and Gingerbread Men Marshmallows: "gelatin (bovine)." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/trees-santa-and-gingerbread-men-marshmallows-12ct-favorite-day-8482/-/A-95088235, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Strawberry and Watermelon Marshmallows including bovine gelatin.
Trader Joe's Strawberry & Watermelon Marshmallows label: "BOVINE GELATIN." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/strawberry-watermelon-marshmallows-080470, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Elyon Marshmallows Natural Vanilla on Hy-Vee.com, including kosher fish gelatin from Nile perch or tilapia and natural vanilla flavors.
Hy-Vee's listing for Elyon Marshmallows Natural Vanilla: "Kosher Fish Gelatin (From Nile Perch or Tilapia)" and "Natural Vanilla Flavors." Screenshot of https://www.hy-vee.com/aisles-online/p/208650/elyon-marshmallows-natural-vanilla, captured November 16, 2026.

When we checked on November 15, 2026, Target showed the Kraft Heinz answers about Jet-Puffed as posted "6 years ago" and "2 years ago." A later Kraft Heinz answer on the Jet-Puffed S'moreMallows page says: "The type of gelatin used in JET-PUFFED Marshmallows and Mallowbits are pork-based." Porcine means from pigs.

Shopper question Are these vegetarian? and Kraft Heinz Team answer: The type of gelatin used in JET-PUFFED Marshmallows and Mallowbits are pork-based.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on Target.com's Jet-Puffed S'moreMallows page: "The type of gelatin used in JET-PUFFED Marshmallows and Mallowbits are pork-based." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/jet-puffed-s-moremallows-21oz/-/A-14883881?showOnlyQuestions=true, captured November 16, 2026.

Pork is forbidden outright. Halal Watch World's standard lists pork among the prohibited foods (HIPS 1001 §1.3.2(b)), and its manufacturing standard states: "Pork-derived gelatin and collagen are impermissible" (HIPS 1003-A §8.6). Every product in the first seven rows of the table fails for that reason.

"Beef or pork" is not better. Kellanova says the choice between beef and pork for Rice Krispies Treats "is based on availability in the marketplace," so a shopper cannot tell which one is in a given box. Even when the gelatin is beef, it is only halal when the cattle were slaughtered according to Islamic law. Halal Watch World's manufacturing standard says that where gelatin is made from animal sources, "the source shall be halal-slaughtered and certified" (HIPS 1003-A §8.6). None of the companies that name beef or bovine gelatin says it comes from halal-slaughtered cattle.

A kosher label does not answer the question either. "Kosher gelatin" tells you the product meets a kosher standard. It does not tell you which animal the gelatin came from, or whether that animal was slaughtered according to Islamic law.

Most store brands and many snack makers do not name the animal at all, and U.S. law does not require them to. In 2017 a spokesperson for the U.S. Food and Drug Administration told the trade publication ConfectioneryNews that "FDA regulations do not require manufacturers to declare the source of the gelatin." Under the Halal Watch standard, an animal ingredient whose source and slaughter are not disclosed is a fail.

ConfectioneryNews article text quoting FDA spokesperson Anne Norris: FDA regulations do not require manufacturers to declare the source of the gelatin.
ConfectioneryNews, August 22, 2017: an FDA spokesperson said "FDA regulations do not require manufacturers to declare the source of the gelatin." Screenshot of https://www.confectionerynews.com/Article/2017/08/22/Hindu-leader-condemns-Wrigley-candies-made-with-beef-sourced-gelatin/, captured November 16, 2026.

What the Companies Say Publicly

For this report, Halal Watch World reviewed the brands' websites and product pages, the ingredient labels published by the companies and by U.S. retailers, and company answers to shoppers on Target.com, on November 15 and 16, 2026. Only a few companies address halal directly, and none of them claims halal certification for these products:

  • Just Born, the maker of PEEPS: "While many of our candies are Kosher, they are not Halal certified."
    Just Born FAQ question Are your candies Halal certified? with the answer: While many of our candies are Kosher, they are not Halal certified.
    Just Born FAQ: "While many of our candies are Kosher, they are not Halal certified." Screenshot of https://www.justborn.com/faqs, captured November 16, 2026.
  • Pop-Tarts: "At this time, no Pop-Tarts® products sold in the United States or Canada are certified as Halal."
    Pop-Tarts FAQ question Are Pop-Tarts halal? with the answer that no Pop-Tarts products sold in the United States or Canada are certified as Halal.
    Pop-Tarts FAQ: "At this time, no Pop-Tarts® products sold in the United States or Canada are certified as Halal." Screenshot of https://www.poptarts.com/en_US/faq.html, captured November 16, 2026.
  • Swiss Miss: "Swiss Miss products are not halal-certified. Some varieties may be suitable based on their ingredients, but we recommend reviewing the ingredient list on the package."
    Swiss Miss FAQ question Is Swiss Miss halal? with the answer that Swiss Miss products are not halal-certified and shoppers should review the ingredient list.
    Swiss Miss FAQ: "Swiss Miss products are not halal-certified." Screenshot of https://www.swissmiss.com/faq, captured November 16, 2026.
  • Aldi: "While there may not be a halal-specific section in our stores, we do stock several items that meet halal requirements. We encourage our customers looking for halal foods to review the ingredients and product information on any of the items they are choosing to ensure the product meets their requirements."
    ALDI help center text: there may not be a halal-specific section in ALDI stores, and customers looking for halal foods should review the ingredients and product information.
    ALDI U.S. Help Center: shoppers are asked "to review the ingredients and product information." Screenshot of https://help.aldi.us/faqs/article/Halal-Certified-Products-Available-At-ALDI, captured November 16, 2026.

Just Born also explains why PEEPS still use pork gelatin: "We have done a great deal of research, analysis and testing using alternative sources of gelatin and have not been able to identify a consistent alternative that provides the same great eating experience that our current gelatin provides." Post Consumer Brands, which makes Malt-O-Meal Marshmallow Mateys, says that "Most of our breakfast cereal products are vegetarian, excluding those containing gelatin," but does not say which animal its gelatin comes from. Campfire says it uses "a special recipe for export to markets in the Middle East," and Doumak, the company that owns Campfire, lists a fish gelatin recipe in the export section of its website. Those export recipes are not what Campfire sells in the United States, and this report does not grade them.

Just Born FAQ question about making PEEPS with vegetarian gelatin and the answer that the company has researched and tested alternative sources of gelatin without finding a consistent alternative.
Just Born FAQ on alternatives: "We have done a great deal of research, analysis and testing using alternative sources of gelatin..." Screenshot of https://www.justborn.com/faqs, captured November 16, 2026.

Recipes also differ by country. Kellanova, which Mars, Incorporated acquired in December 2025, notes that its gelatin information "applies to products made for the United States market. Products sold in other countries may have different ingredients and nutrition information." Trader Joe's defines its vegan claim: a vegan claim on its private label "means the product is free of all animal products and /or by-products," including "meat, poultry, fish, eggs, dairy, honey, gelatin, lanolin, confectioner's glaze, and carmine." Halal Watch World found no halal certification claim on Trader Joe's product pages.

Trader Joe's FAQ text: a vegan claim under Trader Joe's private label means the product is free of all animal products and by-products, including meat, poultry, fish, eggs, dairy, honey, gelatin, lanolin, confectioner's glaze, and carmine.
Trader Joe's Product FAQs: its definition of a vegan claim on its private label. Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/FAQ/product-faqs, captured November 16, 2026.

This report is based on the companies' published information, the Halal Watch ingredient database and Halal Watch World's standards. No company inquiry or laboratory testing was carried out for this report.

How It Is Manufactured

The National Confectioners Association describes how marshmallows are made today: corn syrup, starch, sugar and water are mixed with the gelatin, and "The fluffy mixture is piped through long tubes and then cut into equal pieces." The New York Times Magazine described the early extrusion machines, which "forced the marshmallow slurry through tubes, subjected it to blasts of gas at 200 pounds per square inch, extruded it into long tails and then cut it into bite-size chunks."

Jet-Puffed Marshmallows are made in Kendallville, Indiana. In 2024 the plant manager, Bill Davis, told the Indianapolis Business Journal: "Each day, our skilled technicians freshly bake up to 600,000 pounds of Jet-Puffed Marshmallows using a process that inserts air into each marshmallow." The same report says the Kendallville plant is "the sole producer" of Jet-Puffed and Kraft Caramel products, and that it also makes marshmallow creme. Marshmallow Fluff's maker explains the difference between the two spreads: "Fluff is made by a costly, batch-whipping process. Creme is whipped in a continuous mixing process."

Many marshmallow products sold in the United States are made elsewhere. Target's Favorite Day Halloween Friends and Trees, Santa and Gingerbread Men marshmallows are labeled "PRODUCT OF MALAYSIA." Trader Joe's says its Strawberry & Watermelon Marshmallows are "Whipped up for us in Spain," and its Dark Chocolate Covered Marshmallows package reads "PRODUCT OF FRANCE." Elyon marshmallows are a product of Israel, and Mallomars and Pinwheels are made in Canada. Kellogg's says Rice Krispies Treats are "made and packaged in Rome, GA and most recently also in Linares, Mexico." Stuffed Puffs, whose assets Mount Franklin Foods acquired in 2024, are made in El Paso, Texas, and MoonPies are made in Chattanooga, Tennessee. Where a product is made does not decide its grade. The Favorite Day marshmallows made in Malaysia list bovine gelatin, and Halal Watch World found no halal claim on their Target listings.

Trader Joe's product description: Whipped up for us in Spain by one of Europe's premiere mallow-makers.
Trader Joe's Strawberry & Watermelon Marshmallows page: "Whipped up for us in Spain..." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/strawberry-watermelon-marshmallows-080470, captured November 16, 2026.

Cross-contamination does not change the verdict on the gelatin products, because they already fail on their gelatin. It does matter for gelatin-free marshmallows. Campfire says its marshmallows "are made in an allergy friendly facility," which is an allergen statement and says nothing about gelatin or halal. On its regular Marshmallows page, Trader Joe's says: "We get these melty Mallows from a company that's dedicated to making Marshmallows using vegan ingredients and without artificial flavors or preservatives." Halal Watch World did not confirm which supplier makes the peppermint version.

Trader Joe's Marshmallows product description stating that the marshmallows come from a company dedicated to making marshmallows using vegan ingredients and without artificial flavors or preservatives.
Trader Joe's Marshmallows page: "We get these melty Mallows from a company that's dedicated to making Marshmallows using vegan ingredients and without artificial flavors or preservatives." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/marshmallows-056661, captured November 16, 2026.

Other Marshmallow Products

These are the U.S. products Halal Watch World reviewed for this report, as published on November 15 and 16, 2026. "Animal source made public" means the company has said, on its label or in a public statement, which animal the gelatin comes from.

Regular marshmallows: national brands

Marshmallow product (U.S.)Lists gelatin?Animal source made publicGrade
Jet-Puffed Marshmallows (12 oz, 1 lb and 24 oz)YesPork, per Kraft HeinzFAIL
Jet-Puffed Mini Marshmallows, Jumbo Extra Large and StackersYesPork, per Kraft HeinzFAIL
Jet-Puffed Fruity-Fun Mini, Peppermint Mini and seasonal shapesYesPork, per Kraft HeinzFAIL
Jet-Puffed Vanilla Marshmallow BitsYesPork, per Kraft Heinz ("Mallowbits")FAIL
Jet-Puffed Lucky Charms Magically Delicious MarshmallowsYesPork, per Kraft Heinz's statements about Jet-Puffed marshmallowsFAIL
Campfire marshmallows sold in the U.S. (Regular label checked)YesPork ("porcine"), per CampfireFAIL

Regular marshmallows: store brands

Marshmallow product (U.S.)Lists gelatin?Animal source made publicGrade
Good & Gather Marshmallows and Mini Marshmallows, 10 oz (Target)YesPork, on the labelFAIL
Favorite Day Halloween Friends; Trees, Santa and Gingerbread Men (Target)YesBeef ("bovine"), slaughter not disclosedFAIL
Favorite Day Halloween Ghostly Friends, 8 oz (Target)YesNot disclosedFAIL
Kroger Marshmallows (16 oz) and Kroger Regular Marshmallows (10 oz)YesNot disclosedFAIL
Great Value Marshmallows, 10 oz (Walmart)YesNot disclosedFAIL
Baker's Corner Marshmallows, Mini Marshmallows and Giant Marshmallows (Aldi)YesNot disclosedFAIL
Specially Selected Premium Peppermint Marshmallows, 4.5 oz (Aldi)Yes ("Kosher Gelatin")Not disclosedFAIL
Specially Selected Vanilla Bean, Cinnamon Churro and Salted Caramel Marshmallows (Aldi)No ingredient list published onlineNot applicableNot graded in this report
365 by Whole Foods Market Mini and Large Marshmallows, 10 ozYesNot disclosedFAIL
Trader Joe's Strawberry & Watermelon MarshmallowsYesBeef ("BOVINE"), slaughter not disclosedFAIL
Trader Joe's Snowflake MarshmallowsYesPork, on the labelFAIL

Gelatin-free and fish-gelatin marshmallows

Marshmallow product (U.S.)Lists gelatin?Animal source made publicGrade
Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows, 6 oz (seasonal)NoNot applicablePASS
Trader Joe's Marshmallows and Mini Marshmallows, 10 ozNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (natural vanilla flavor of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Trader Joe's Mini Maple Flavored MarshmallowsNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (natural flavors of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Trader Joe's Marshmallow EggsNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (natural flavors of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Dandies Classic Vanilla MarshmallowsNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (natural vanilla flavor of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Elyon Marshmallows and Miniature Marshmallows, Natural VanillaYes, fish gelatinFish ("Nile Perch or Tilapia"), per the labelDOUBTFUL (vanilla flavors of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)

Marshmallow candies and filled marshmallows

Marshmallow product (U.S.)Lists gelatin?Animal source made publicGrade
PEEPS Marshmallow Chicks and Bunnies, Cotton Candy, Milk Chocolate Delights, and Halloween and Christmas shapesYesPork, per Just BornFAIL (Pink Bunnies also list carmine)
Stuffed Puffs Classic Milk Chocolate, Salted Caramel and Milk Chocolate MinisYesNot disclosedFAIL
Stuffed Puffs Gummy Fuzions (Fruity Punch, Mixed Berry, Chili Mango, Sour Watermelon, Sour Berry)YesNot disclosedFAIL
Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Covered MarshmallowsYesPork, on the packageFAIL
Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Dipped Candy Cane MarshmallowsNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (natural flavors of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Favorite Day Dark Chocolate with Peppermint Giant Marshmallow, White Chocolaty Coated Stirrers and Hot Cocoa Spoon (Target)YesNot disclosedFAIL
Two rows of yellow and pink PEEPS marshmallow chicks
PEEPS marshmallow chicks, made by Just Born. Photo: Evan-Amos, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Marshmallow creme and fluff

Marshmallow product (U.S.)Lists gelatin?Animal source made publicGrade
Jet-Puffed Marshmallow CremeNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (flavor of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Marshmallow Fluff, Original and StrawberryNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (flavor of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)

Cereals with marshmallows

Cereal (U.S.)Lists gelatin?Animal source made publicGrade
Lucky Charms Original, Jumbo Rainbow and Chocolatey ChocolateYesPork, per General MillsFAIL (also list carmine)
Lucky Charms Berry Swirl, Minis and S'moresYesPork, per General MillsFAIL
Lucky Charms Just Magical Marshmallows pouch, 4 ozYesPork, per General Mills (the same marbits as in the cereal)FAIL
Count Chocula, Boo Berry, Frankenberry and Reduced Sugar Cocoa Puffs with marshmallowsYes, per General Mills (labels not reviewed individually)Pork, per General MillsFAIL
Malt-O-Meal Marshmallow Mateys, Chocolate Marshmallow Mateys, Berry Colossal Crunch, Cocoa Dyno-Bites, Fruity Dyno-Bites and S'moresYesNot disclosedFAIL
Post Honey Maid S'mores, Marshmallow Fruity Pebbles and Oreo PuffsYesNot disclosedFAIL
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Galaxy Marshmallow CerealYesNot disclosedFAIL
A close-up of Lucky Charms cereal with its colored marshmallow pieces
Lucky Charms cereal and its marshmallow pieces, which General Mills calls marbits. Photo: m01229, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Snacks, cookies and treats

Snack (U.S.)Lists gelatin?Animal source made publicGrade
Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats: Original, Homestyle, Rainbow, Confetti Cake, Squishmallows, Bliss and Double Chocolatey ChunkYesBeef or pork, per KellanovaFAIL
Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats Chocolatey Peanut ButterNo (uses agar)Not applicableDOUBTFUL (flavors of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Lucky Charms Treat BarsYesPork in the marbits, per General MillsFAIL (also list carmine)
Trader Joe's Crispy Rice BarsYesPork, on the labelFAIL
Trader Joe's S'mores ClustersNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (natural flavor of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Pop-Tarts Frosted S'mores (s'mores-flavored; gelatin in the icing)YesBeef, per Kellanova; slaughter not disclosedFAIL
MoonPie Single-Decker, Double-Decker, Mini and Birthday MinisYesPork ("porkskin"), per Chattanooga BakeryFAIL
Nabisco Mallomars and PinwheelsYesNot disclosedFAIL
Little Debbie Marshmallow Pies (Chocolate and Banana) and Easter Marshmallow PuffsYes ("Kosher Gelatin")Not disclosedFAIL
Little Debbie Marshmallow TreatYesNot disclosedFAIL
Hostess Sno Balls, Holiday Sno Balls and GloBallsYes, plus tallowNot disclosedFAIL (pink Sno Balls and GloBalls also list carmine)
Hostess S'mores Cupcakes (s'mores-flavored)No, but lists tallowTallow (animal fat), slaughter not disclosedFAIL
A Double-Decker MoonPie cut in half, showing marshmallow filling between graham cookie layers
A Double-Decker MoonPie made by Chattanooga Bakery. Photo: Evan-Amos, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Hot cocoa and ice cream

Product (U.S.)Lists gelatin?Animal source made publicGrade
Swiss Miss hot cocoa with marshmallows: Milk Chocolate with Marshmallows, Marshmallow Lovers, canisters, variety pack, Unicorn Marshmallows and Lucky Charms MarshmallowsYesBeef and/or pork, per Swiss MissFAIL
Ben & Jerry's Phish Food, PB S'more, Gimme S'more! and Marshmallow SkyNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (natural flavor of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)
Ben & Jerry's Phish Food Non-DairyNoNot applicableDOUBTFUL (natural flavor of undisclosed source; we advise refraining)

Kraft Heinz's answers refer to the gelatin in "JET-PUFFED Marshmallows" and "Mallowbits" in general. Even if a particular shape used a different gelatin, Kraft Heinz does not disclose a halal-slaughtered source for any of them, so every Jet-Puffed product whose label lists gelatin fails under the Halal Watch standard.

Doubtful: gelatin-free products whose flavor source is not disclosed

A label without gelatin is not automatically halal. Trader Joe's Marshmallows, Mini Marshmallows, Mini Maple Flavored Marshmallows, Marshmallow Eggs, Dark Chocolate Dipped Candy Cane Marshmallows and S'mores Clusters, Dandies, Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme, Marshmallow Fluff, Rice Krispies Treats Chocolatey Peanut Butter and the five Ben & Jerry's flavors above are made without gelatin, and Elyon uses fish gelatin. But each lists a natural or artificial flavor whose source is not disclosed. In the Halal Watch ingredient database, flavors whose make-up is not disclosed are marked doubtful as "Unknown ingredients."

Halal Watch World's ruling for these cases is that such an ingredient is doubtful, and that the likelihood of a haram source is high enough that we should refrain from it until the source is disclosed. That follows the hadith on doubtful matters quoted in full under The Religious Basis below (Sahih al-Bukhari 52). These products are therefore graded DOUBTFUL, and we advise refraining from them.

To show why, the paragraphs below set out what U.S. law and published figures say about flavors and emulsifiers, and what each company discloses about the source of ingredients in its other products. Some of these clues point toward a plant source and some point toward a haram one. None of the companies discloses the source of the flavor in the products graded here.

What "natural flavor" can mean

U.S. law lets one word cover very different sources. The federal definition of natural flavor, 21 CFR 101.22(a)(3), covers flavoring constituents "derived from a spice, fruit or fruit juice, vegetable or vegetable juice, edible yeast, herb, bark, bud, root, leaf or similar plant material, meat, seafood, poultry, eggs, dairy products, or fermentation products thereof." Trader Joe's quotes the same definition on its own Product FAQs page. A 2023 technical report for the U.S. Department of Agriculture's National Organic Program adds: "Flavors are also derived from animals as both slaughter and non-slaughter products." Halal Watch World's manufacturing standard says of flavors: "Halal review focuses on solvents, animal-derived flavor components, and processing aids" (HIPS 1003-A §8.5). Halal Watch World found no reliable published figure for the share of natural flavors that come from animals, so we do not give one.

Text of 21 CFR 101.22(a)(3) on eCFR defining natural flavor as including constituents derived from plant material, meat, seafood, poultry, eggs, dairy products, or fermentation products.
The federal definition of natural flavor, 21 CFR 101.22(a)(3), includes "meat, seafood, poultry, eggs, dairy products." Screenshot of https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-B/part-101/subpart-B/section-101.22, captured November 16, 2026.
Trader Joe's FAQ text quoting the FDA definition of natural flavors, which includes meat, seafood, poultry, eggs and dairy products.
Trader Joe's quotes the same FDA definition on its own Product FAQs page. Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/FAQ/product-faqs, captured November 16, 2026.
Excerpt from a 2023 USDA technical report: Flavors are also derived from animals as both slaughter and non-slaughter products, including dairy and egg derivatives.
USDA flavors report, 2023: "Flavors are also derived from animals as both slaughter and non-slaughter products." From USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, National Organic Program, "Flavors," Limited Scope Technical Report (Handling), April 11, 2023, PDF page 7, https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/LimitedScopeTechnicalReportFlavorsHandling2023.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.

Alcohol in flavors

Many flavors are made or carried in alcohol. The same USDA report describes "the percolation of plant raw material in an ethanol solution" and states: "Ethanol is an acceptable solvent to produce nonorganic flavors used in organic production." Vanilla is the clearest case. Under 21 CFR 169.175, in vanilla extract "the content of ethyl alcohol is not less than 35 percent by volume," and under 21 CFR 169.177, vanilla flavoring conforms to the standard for vanilla extract "except that its content of ethyl alcohol is less than 35 percent by volume." Halal Watch World's manufacturing standard states: "Vanilla extract is traditionally an ethanol extraction of vanilla beans, with the extract itself typically containing 35% ethanol or higher as a carrier" (HIPS 1003-A §8.5). On the source of that alcohol, it states: "Ethanol from grape, date, or barley sources is impermissible in halal product. Ethanol from petrochemical, synthetic, or non-grape/date/barley fermentation sources is permissible up to the negligible-amount threshold of 0.5% v/v in finished product (or 0.1% in certain jurisdictions), provided it was not produced with the intent to intoxicate" (HIPS 1003-A §5.2). None of the companies in this group says where the alcohol in its flavors, if any, comes from.

For vanilla flavors in general, the vanillin maker Borregaard estimates on an undated page: "Today, around 88% of vanilla flavourings come from synthetic vanillin derived from crude oil, 11,5% is plant-based vanillin, and 0,5% comes from the vanilla bean." That is a manufacturer's estimate for vanilla flavorings in general, not for any product here. Vanillin made from crude oil does not come from any of the sources in the natural flavor definition above, so the figure says more about artificial vanilla flavors, such as Marshmallow Fluff's, than about the natural vanilla flavors in the other products.

Excerpt from a 2023 USDA technical report describing percolation of plant material in an ethanol solution and stating that ethanol is an acceptable solvent to produce nonorganic flavors.
The same USDA report: "Ethanol is an acceptable solvent to produce nonorganic flavors used in organic production." From USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, National Organic Program, "Flavors," Limited Scope Technical Report (Handling), April 11, 2023, PDF page 14, https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/LimitedScopeTechnicalReportFlavorsHandling2023.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.
Text of 21 CFR 169.175 on eCFR: vanilla extract is a solution in aqueous ethyl alcohol, and its ethyl alcohol content is not less than 35 percent by volume.
21 CFR 169.175: in vanilla extract "the content of ethyl alcohol is not less than 35 percent by volume." Screenshot of https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-B/part-169/subpart-B/section-169.175, captured November 16, 2026.
Text of 21 CFR 169.177 on eCFR: vanilla flavoring follows the vanilla extract standard except that its ethyl alcohol content is less than 35 percent by volume.
21 CFR 169.177: vanilla flavoring is the same except that "its content of ethyl alcohol is less than 35 percent by volume." Screenshot of https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-B/part-169/subpart-B/section-169.177, captured November 16, 2026.
Borregaard web page text: around 88 percent of vanilla flavourings come from synthetic vanillin derived from crude oil, 11.5 percent is plant-based vanillin and 0.5 percent comes from the vanilla bean.
Borregaard, a vanillin maker (undated page): "around 88% of vanilla flavourings come from synthetic vanillin derived from crude oil." Screenshot of https://www.borregaard.com/product-areas/biovanillin/your-guide-to-plant-based-vanillin, captured November 16, 2026.

Emulsifiers

Only one product in this group, Rice Krispies Treats Chocolatey Peanut Butter, lists emulsifiers other than soy lecithin: DATEM and acetylated monoglycerides. The USDA's 2015 technical report on mono- and diglycerides says their edible sources "are commonly animal fats or vegetable oils such as soybean, canola, sunflower, cottonseed, coconut or palm oil." Halal Watch World's manufacturing standard lists "monoglycerides and diglycerides (animal- or plant-derived), and DATEM (diacetyl tartaric acid esters of mono- and diglycerides)" and states: "Each shall be verified" (HIPS 1003-A §8.11). Halal Watch World found no reliable published figure for the share of these emulsifiers made from animal fat, so we do not give one. Soy lecithin and vegetable glycerin, which several of these products list, name a plant source and are halal in our database.

Excerpt from a 2015 USDA technical report: mono- and diglycerides are made from edible sources that are commonly animal fats or vegetable oils such as soybean, canola, sunflower, cottonseed, coconut or palm oil.
USDA glycerides report, 2015: the edible sources of mono- and diglycerides "are commonly animal fats or vegetable oils." From USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, National Organic Program, "Glycerides (mono and di), Handling/Processing," Technical Evaluation Report, January 27, 2015, PDF page 2, https://www.ams.usda.gov/sites/default/files/media/Glycerides%20TR%202015.pdf, downloaded November 16, 2026.

What the companies disclose elsewhere

Trader Joe's. Trader Joe's says its regular Marshmallows come from "a company that's dedicated to making Marshmallows using vegan ingredients and without artificial flavors or preservatives" (screenshot under How It Is Manufactured, above), and it describes its Peppermint Mini Marshmallows as "gluten free, gelatin free, vegan, and kosher (pareve), just like our other 'mallows." Under Trader Joe's own definition, a vegan claim on its private label "means the product is free of all animal products and /or by-products." These statements point to a plant source for the flavor in the regular and mini marshmallows. They do not say whether the flavor was made or carried in alcohol, or where that alcohol came from. Trader Joe's does show that its vanilla ingredients can contain alcohol: its Gluten Free Double Chocolate Muffins list "VANILLA EXTRACT (WATER, ETHYL ALCOHOL, VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES)." The Mini Maple Flavored Marshmallows, Marshmallow Eggs, Dark Chocolate Dipped Candy Cane Marshmallows and S'mores Clusters list natural flavors in the same way, and Halal Watch World found no Trader Joe's statement about the source of those flavors.

Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Gluten Free Double Chocolate Muffins including vanilla extract made of water, ethyl alcohol and vanilla bean extractives.
Another Trader Joe's product, Gluten Free Double Chocolate Muffins, spells out its vanilla extract: "WATER, ETHYL ALCOHOL, VANILLA BEAN EXTRACTIVES." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/gluten-free-double-chocolate-muffins-074110, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Mini Maple Flavored Marshmallows including natural flavors and maple syrup; no gelatin.
Trader Joe's Mini Maple Flavored Marshmallows: "NATURAL FLAVORS." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/mini-maple-flavored-marshmallows-076219, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Marshmallow Eggs including natural flavors; no gelatin.
Trader Joe's Marshmallow Eggs: "NATURAL FLAVORS." Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/marshmallow-eggs-083321, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Dipped Candy Cane Marshmallows including natural flavors and natural vanilla flavor; no gelatin.
Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Dipped Candy Cane Marshmallows: natural flavors in the marshmallow and natural vanilla flavor in the chocolate. Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/dark-chocolate-dipped-candy-cane-marshmallows-079214, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Trader Joe's S'mores Clusters: milk chocolate, mini marshmallows and graham cracker, with natural vanilla flavor and natural flavor; no gelatin.
Trader Joe's S'mores Clusters: natural vanilla flavor in the chocolate and the mini marshmallows, and natural flavor in the graham cracker. Screenshot of https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/smores-clusters-076559, captured November 16, 2026.

Dandies. Dandies' maker, Chicago Vegan Foods, says on its foodservice page: "Elevate your products with our plant-based marshmallows." That points to a plant source for the "Natural Vanilla Flavor." It does not say whether the flavor was made or carried in alcohol, or where that alcohol came from.

Dandies ingredient list: tapioca syrup, cane sugar, filtered water, tapioca starch, carrageenan, soy protein, natural vanilla flavor.
Dandies Classic Vanilla Marshmallows: "Natural Vanilla Flavor." Screenshot of https://dandies.com/dandies-marshmallows, captured November 16, 2026.
Dandies foodservice page text: Elevate your products with our plant-based marshmallows.
Dandies foodservice page: "Elevate your products with our plant-based marshmallows." Screenshot of https://dandies.com/foodservice, captured November 16, 2026.

Kraft Heinz (Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme). Kraft Heinz says its Marshmallow Creme "does not contain animal gelatin at all," and the creme's only animal ingredient is dried egg white, which is halal in our database. Kraft Heinz has not said what its "ARTIFICIAL AND NATURAL FLAVOR" is made from. Two other Kraft Heinz answers on Target.com point in different directions. On alcohol, it explains: "Alcohol in foods is sometimes used as a preservative or in the manufacturing of some flavors and aromas used in foods." It adds that when vanilla extract is used in another food, "because the alcohol has no technical function in the cookie and is present in such a minute amount, it would not be required to be labeled on the ingredient line of the cookies." So a label can list a flavor without showing the alcohol used to make it. On mono- and diglycerides, which the creme does not contain, it says: "Monoglycerides and diglycerides in our products are made from vegetable oils." The same company uses pork gelatin in Jet-Puffed Marshmallows, as its answers in the gallery above show.

Kraft Heinz ingredient list for Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme: corn syrup, sugar, water, less than 2 percent of dried egg whites, cream of tartar, xanthan gum, artificial and natural flavor.
Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme on Kraft Heinz's product page: "ARTIFICIAL AND NATURAL FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://www.kraftheinz.com/jet-puffed/products/00600699661447-marshmallow-creme, captured November 16, 2026.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on Target.com: the creme does not contain animal gelatin and uses dried egg whites, cream of tartar and xanthan gum.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on Target.com's Marshmallow Creme page: "No, it does not contain animal gelatin at all." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/-/A-12968788?showOnlyQuestions=true, captured November 16, 2026.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on Target.com: alcohol is sometimes used in making flavors, and when vanilla extract is used in another food the alcohol would not be required to be labeled.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on Target.com's JELL-O Instant Sugar Free Vanilla Pudding page, replying to a shopper's question about sugar alcohols: "Alcohol in foods is sometimes used as a preservative or in the manufacturing of some flavors and aromas used in foods." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/-/A-12985357?showOnlyQuestions=true, captured November 16, 2026.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on Target.com: Monoglycerides and diglycerides in our products are made from vegetable oils.
Kraft Heinz Team answer on the same JELL-O page: "Monoglycerides and diglycerides in our products are made from vegetable oils." Screenshot of https://www.target.com/p/-/A-12985357?showOnlyQuestions=true, captured November 16, 2026.

Durkee-Mower (Marshmallow Fluff). Marshmallow Fluff's labels list "ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR" (Original) and "NATURAL & ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR" (Strawberry). Its maker's FAQ says: "There are no artificial preservatives, stabilizers or emulsifiers in any of our products." The same FAQ, as archived on April 18, 2017, said: "Marshmallow Fluff contains Corn Syrup, Sugar Syrup, Dried Egg Whites and Vanillin." Today it says "Dried Egg Whites and Artificial Flavor." Vanillin is halal in our database, so the 2017 wording points toward a synthetic flavor in the Original. But the current label and FAQ no longer name vanillin, the company does not say what the Strawberry version's natural flavor is made from, and neither says what carrier is used. Fluff therefore stays doubtful.

Marshmallow Fluff ingredient list: corn syrup, sugar, egg white, artificial flavor.
Marshmallow Fluff Original label: "ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://marshmallowfluff.com/nutritionfacts/, captured November 16, 2026.
Strawberry Marshmallow Fluff ingredient list including beet juice color and natural and artificial flavor.
Strawberry Marshmallow Fluff label: "NATURAL & ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://marshmallowfluff.com/nutritionfacts/, captured November 16, 2026.
Marshmallow Fluff FAQ What is Fluff made from? listing corn syrup, sugar syrup, dried egg whites and artificial flavor, and stating there are no artificial preservatives, stabilizers or emulsifiers.
Current Fluff FAQ: "Dried Egg Whites and Artificial Flavor," and "There are no artificial preservatives, stabilizers or emulsifiers in any of our products." Screenshot of https://marshmallowfluff.com/faq/, captured November 16, 2026.
Archived 2017 Marshmallow Fluff FAQ: Marshmallow Fluff contains corn syrup, sugar syrup, dried egg whites and vanillin.
The same Fluff FAQ as archived on April 18, 2017: "Marshmallow Fluff contains Corn Syrup, Sugar Syrup, Dried Egg Whites and Vanillin." Screenshot of https://web.archive.org/web/20170418084332/https://www.marshmallowfluff.com/faq/, captured November 16, 2026.

Kellanova (Rice Krispies Treats Chocolatey Peanut Butter). Kellanova's U.S. FAQ lists "Emulsifiers (including monoglycerides, diglycerides and polysorbate)" and "Glycerin" under "Non-Animal Sources," for "products made for the United States market." That is a company-wide statement rather than a statement about this bar, but it points to a non-animal source for the bar's DATEM and acetylated monoglycerides. The bar's dairy ingredients, whey, nonfat milk and lactose, are halal under Halal Watch World's standard. For flavors, the clearest Kellanova statement comes from MorningStar Farms, a brand that its FAQ says "is owned by Kellanova": "We have confirmed that our natural flavors do not include castoreum or any meat ingredients." That statement is about MorningStar Farms products, not Rice Krispies Treats. Kellanova has not said what the bar's "natural and artificial flavors" are made from, and it uses beef or pork gelatin in every other Rice Krispies Treats variety in this report.

Ingredient list for Rice Krispies Treats Chocolatey Peanut Butter bars including vegetable glycerin, natural and artificial flavors, agar, DATEM, soy lecithin and acetylated monoglycerides.
Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats Chocolatey Peanut Butter: "natural and artificial flavors, agar, DATEM, soy lecithin, acetylated monoglycerides." Screenshot of https://www.ricekrispiestreats.com/en-us/products/rkt-squares-chocolatey-peanut-butter.html, captured November 16, 2026.
Kellanova FAQ answer for products made for the United States market listing non-animal sources, including emulsifiers (monoglycerides, diglycerides and polysorbate) and glycerin, and animal sources, including eggs, dairy and gelatin.
Kellanova U.S. FAQ, "Vegan and Vegetarian - Ingredients": emulsifiers and glycerin are listed under "Non-Animal Sources" for products made for the U.S. market. Tap to enlarge. Screenshot of https://kelloggconsumeraffairs.my.salesforce-sites.com/kwFAQKellogs?website=Kelloggs%20US, captured November 16, 2026.
MorningStar Farms FAQ question What is in MorningStar Farms natural flavors? with the answer that its natural flavors come from fruits, vegetables and spices and do not include castoreum or any meat ingredients.
MorningStar Farms FAQ: "We have confirmed that our natural flavors do not include castoreum or any meat ingredients." Screenshot of https://www.morningstarfarms.com/en_US/faq.html, captured November 16, 2026.

Ben & Jerry's. Each of the five Ben & Jerry's labels lists "NATURAL FLAVOR." Ben & Jerry's UK website says: "we don't use any meat products, including gelatine, so even our Phish Food marshmallow swirl is veggie-friendly!" On its U.S. allergens page, the company says its Non-Dairy flavors are certified as not including "animal products of any kind, including eggs, dairy, or honey." Those statements point away from meat in the flavor. But the company's U.S. FAQ also says: "Rest assured the trace amount of liqueur or caffeine used in our flavorings is perfectly safe for you to consume." A liqueur is an alcoholic drink, and the company does not say which flavors use it. This is the clearest statement in this report that points toward a haram ingredient in a flavoring.

Ingredient list for Ben and Jerry's Phish Food ice cream including natural flavor; no gelatin.
Ben & Jerry's Phish Food ingredients: "NATURAL FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/phish-food-ice-cream, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Ben and Jerry's PB S'more ice cream including natural flavor; no gelatin.
Ben & Jerry's PB S'more ingredients: "NATURAL FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/pb-smore-ice-cream, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Ben and Jerry's Gimme S'more ice cream including natural flavor; no gelatin.
Ben & Jerry's Gimme S'more! ingredients: "NATURAL FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/gimme-smore-ice-cream, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Ben and Jerry's Marshmallow Sky ice cream including natural flavor; no gelatin.
Ben & Jerry's Marshmallow Sky ingredients: "NATURAL FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/marshmallow-sky-ice-cream, captured November 16, 2026.
Ingredient list for Ben and Jerry's Phish Food Non-Dairy oat frozen dessert including natural flavor.
Ben & Jerry's Phish Food Non-Dairy ingredients: "NATURAL FLAVOR." Screenshot of https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/phish-food-non-dairy, captured November 16, 2026.
Ben and Jerry's FAQ Can pregnant people eat Ben and Jerry's ice cream? with the answer mentioning the trace amount of liqueur or caffeine used in its flavorings.
Ben & Jerry's Contact Us FAQ: "the trace amount of liqueur or caffeine used in our flavorings is perfectly safe for you to consume." Screenshot of https://www.benjerry.com/contact-us, captured November 16, 2026.
Ben and Jerry's UK web page text: we don't use any meat products, including gelatine, so even our Phish Food marshmallow swirl is veggie-friendly.
Ben & Jerry's UK site: "we don't use any meat products, including gelatine." Screenshot of https://www.benjerry.co.uk/values/issues-we-care-about/veggie-friendly, captured November 16, 2026.

In short, for each of these products the decisive facts, the source of the flavor and of any alcohol used to make it, are not disclosed. Some companies' statements make a plant source more likely. Others show that alcohol, pork or beef are used elsewhere in the same company's products. Halal Watch World grades all of them DOUBTFUL and advises refraining from them. If a company discloses the source, or a product is certified halal, we will review it again.

Elyon is the only brand in this report that names a fish as the source of its gelatin. Halal Watch World's standard lists "animals that come from the ocean" among the foods that are permissible by default (HIPS 1001 §1.4.1.1). Its definition of seafood also covers fish from rivers and lakes: "Edible aquatic animals or plants taken from the sea or other bodies of water" (HIPS 1001 §2.5.17). The fish gelatin is therefore not the problem. Elyon marshmallows are graded DOUBTFUL because the source of their vanilla flavors is not disclosed, and Halal Watch World found no statement from Elyon's producer about it. We advise refraining from them.

Some products would fail even without their gelatin. PEEPS Pink Bunnies, Lucky Charms Original, Jumbo Rainbow and Chocolatey Chocolate, Lucky Charms Treat Bars, and the pink Hostess Sno Balls and GloBalls list carmine, a red color made from insects. Halal Watch World's manufacturing standard states that carmine "is derived from insects and is impermissible under HIPS 1001 §1.3.2(h)." Hostess Sno Balls, GloBalls and S'mores Cupcakes also list tallow, an animal fat. Under the same standard, animal-derived oils such as tallow "require halal certification," and Hostess does not disclose a halal source, so the S'mores Cupcakes fail even though they list no gelatin.

Recipes also differ by market. Campfire says it makes a special recipe for export to the Middle East, and Halal Watch World has not reviewed or graded it. Halal Watch World also did not review every store brand, flavor or seasonal shape. Always read the label on the pack in your hand.

The Religious Basis

Allah has forbidden the flesh of animals that die without proper slaughter, along with swine:

حُرِّمَتْ عَلَيْكُمُ ٱلْمَيْتَةُ وَٱلدَّمُ وَلَحْمُ ٱلْخِنزِيرِ وَمَآ أُهِلَّ لِغَيْرِ ٱللَّهِ بِهِۦ

"Prohibited to you are dead animals, blood, the flesh of swine, and that which has been dedicated to other than Allāh"

Qur'an, Surah Al-Ma'idah 5:3, opening of the verse, Saheeh International translation

And He commanded that we not eat what was slaughtered without His name:

وَلَا تَأْكُلُوا۟ مِمَّا لَمْ يُذْكَرِ ٱسْمُ ٱللَّهِ عَلَيْهِ وَإِنَّهُۥ لَفِسْقٌ

"And do not eat of that upon which the name of Allāh has not been mentioned, for indeed, it is grave disobedience."

Qur'an, Surah Al-An'am 6:121, opening of the verse, Saheeh International translation

Halal Watch World's Certification Methodology & Analysis Report applies these verses to meat in the United States: "non-religious meat slaughtered in the US is not permissible to consume carte blanche, and requires verification to determine its permissibility. Absent a declaration that the proper method of slaughter was performed, no permission to consume exists, and should not be assumed."

The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) also taught how to treat the uncertain cases in between, which is why doubtful ingredients such as undisclosed flavors call for caution:

الْحَلاَلُ بَيِّنٌ وَالْحَرَامُ بَيِّنٌ، وَبَيْنَهُمَا مُشَبَّهَاتٌ لاَ يَعْلَمُهَا كَثِيرٌ مِنَ النَّاسِ، فَمَنِ اتَّقَى الْمُشَبَّهَاتِ اسْتَبْرَأَ لِدِيِنِهِ وَعِرْضِهِ

"Both legal and illegal things are evident but in between them there are doubtful (suspicious) things and most of the people have no knowledge about them. So whoever saves himself from these suspicious things saves his religion and his honor."

Sahih al-Bukhari 52, narrated by An-Nu'man bin Bashir, opening portion; also reported in Sahih Muslim 1599

How We Graded

Halal Watch's standard starts from a basic principle of Islamic dietary law: food is presumed permissible unless something known makes it haram. Suspicion alone does not make a food haram, but it can make it doubtful.

Animal ingredients are different. Meat, and anything made from it, needs positive evidence of proper slaughter before it is permitted. So Halal Watch grades products this way:

  • FAIL: the product contains a documented haram ingredient, or an animal-derived ingredient whose animal source and slaughter are not disclosed.
  • DOUBTFUL: a genuine concern remains unresolved. This includes a flavor, emulsifier, glycerin or lecithin that could come from a plant or an animal, or could be made with alcohol, when the company does not disclose its source. We advise refraining from doubtful products until the source is disclosed.
  • PASS: the evidence is clear. A pass is not a halal certification.

Products whose gelatin is pork, by the company's own statement or label, fail on a documented haram ingredient. Products with beef, "beef or pork," kosher or unidentified gelatin fail because the animal source or the slaughter is not disclosed. The same rule applies to tallow. Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows pass because every ingredient is halal in our database or under a clear Halal Watch World standard, and none of them comes from an animal. Products with no haram ingredient and no undisclosed animal-only ingredient, whose open question is a flavor or emulsifier of undisclosed source, are graded DOUBTFUL, and we advise refraining from them. This includes Elyon's fish-gelatin marshmallows. Products whose ingredient list is not published, such as three Aldi Specially Selected marshmallows, are not graded.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are any marshmallows halal?

Of the big-brand products in this report, one passes: Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows, a seasonal product made without gelatin or any other animal ingredient. Several other marshmallows, including Trader Joe's regular marshmallows and Dandies (made without gelatin) and Elyon (made with fish gelatin), are graded doubtful because the source of their flavorings is not disclosed, and we advise refraining from them. For other brands, look for a halal certification on the package.

Do marshmallows have pork?

Many do. Kraft Heinz says the gelatin in Jet-Puffed Marshmallows is pork-based, Campfire says its U.S. marshmallows are made with porcine gelatin, and Just Born, General Mills and Chattanooga Bakery say the gelatin in PEEPS, Lucky Charms marshmallows and MoonPies comes from pork. Target's Good & Gather marshmallows list "gelatin (pork)" on the label.

Are Lucky Charms halal?

No. General Mills says "The gelatin in our marshmallow marbit pieces is made from pork collagen," and lists Lucky Charms, Chocolate Lucky Charms, Reduced Sugar Cocoa Puffs with marshmallows, Count Chocula, Boo Berry and Frankenberry as cereals that contain marbits. Lucky Charms Original, Jumbo Rainbow and Chocolatey Chocolate also list carmine.

Are PEEPS halal?

No. Just Born says "The gelatin used in our marshmallow candies is derived from pork products," and that its candies "are not Halal certified."

Are Rice Krispies Treats halal?

No. Kellanova says the gelatin in all varieties of Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats is "derived from EITHER Beef or Pork," depending on availability. The Chocolatey Peanut Butter bars are made with agar instead of gelatin, but they are graded doubtful because the source of their natural and artificial flavors is not disclosed, and we advise refraining from them.

Are s'mores Pop-Tarts halal?

Frosted S'mores Pop-Tarts fail. Kellanova says beef gelatin is used in the icing of frosted Pop-Tarts and does not say the cattle were slaughtered according to Islamic law. Pop-Tarts also says no Pop-Tarts products sold in the United States or Canada "are certified as Halal." Kellanova says unfrosted Pop-Tarts contain no gelatin; they are not reviewed in this report.

Is Swiss Miss with marshmallows halal?

No. Swiss Miss says its marshmallow gelatin "is derived from collagen from beef and/or pork bones," and that "Swiss Miss products are not halal-certified."

Are Trader Joe's marshmallows halal?

It depends on the product. Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows pass. Trader Joe's regular and mini marshmallows are made without gelatin but are graded doubtful, because the source of their natural vanilla flavor is not disclosed, and we advise refraining from them. Some Trader Joe's marshmallow products, including Snowflake Marshmallows, Crispy Rice Bars and Dark Chocolate Covered Marshmallows, list pork gelatin, and Strawberry & Watermelon Marshmallows list bovine gelatin.

Are vegan or gelatin-free marshmallows halal?

Removing gelatin removes the main problem, but it does not make a marshmallow halal on its own. Flavors and other ingredients still matter. Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows pass because every ingredient is accounted for. Other gelatin-free marshmallows in this report are graded doubtful because the source of their flavorings is not disclosed, and we advise refraining from them.

Are Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme and Marshmallow Fluff halal?

Neither contains gelatin. Kraft Heinz says its Marshmallow Creme "does not contain animal gelatin at all," and Marshmallow Fluff is made from corn syrup, sugar, egg white and artificial flavor. Both are graded doubtful because the source of their flavor is not disclosed, and we advise refraining from them.

Is beef gelatin halal?

Only when it comes from cattle slaughtered according to Islamic law and the gelatin is certified halal. Beef gelatin with no evidence of halal slaughter does not meet the Halal Watch standard.

Is kosher gelatin halal?

A kosher label alone does not make gelatin halal under the Halal Watch standard. "Kosher gelatin" does not tell you which animal the gelatin came from or whether that animal was slaughtered according to Islamic law, so products that list only "kosher gelatin" fail.

Is fish gelatin halal?

Elyon is the only brand in this report that uses fish gelatin, and its label names the fish: "Nile Perch or Tilapia." Halal Watch World's standard lists "animals that come from the ocean" among the foods that are permissible by default. Elyon marshmallows are graded doubtful because the source of their vanilla flavors is not disclosed, and we advise refraining from them.

Are store-brand marshmallows halal?

None of the store-brand gelatin marshmallows in this report passes. Target's Good & Gather marshmallows list pork gelatin and some Favorite Day marshmallows list bovine gelatin. Kroger, Great Value, Aldi's Baker's Corner and 365 by Whole Foods Market list gelatin without naming the animal, and Aldi's Specially Selected Peppermint Marshmallows list "Kosher Gelatin." Halal Watch World did not review every store brand, so check the label on the pack you are buying.

Are Jet-Puffed and Campfire marshmallows halal?

Not the ones sold in the United States. Kraft Heinz says the gelatin in Jet-Puffed Marshmallows is pork-based, and Halal Watch World found no halal certification claim on Kraft Heinz's Jet-Puffed product page. Campfire says its marshmallows are made with porcine gelatin. Its special export recipe for the Middle East is not what it sells in the United States, and Halal Watch World has not reviewed or graded it.

Are MoonPies halal?

No. Chattanooga Bakery says: "We use porkskin gelatin."

Final Verdict – Marshmallows

FAIL for almost every big-brand marshmallow product sold in the United States that contains gelatin. Jet-Puffed, Campfire, PEEPS, Lucky Charms marshmallows and MoonPie use pork gelatin, according to the companies themselves. Pork is haram. Rice Krispies Treats and Swiss Miss marshmallows may contain beef or pork gelatin, frosted Pop-Tarts and some store-brand marshmallows use beef gelatin with no evidence of halal slaughter, and most store brands and snack makers do not disclose the animal at all. All of them fail under the Halal Watch standard.

PASS for Trader Joe's Peppermint Mini Marshmallows. They are made without gelatin or any other animal ingredient, and every ingredient is halal in our database or under Halal Watch World's standard. They are a seasonal product, and a pass is not a halal certification.

DOUBTFUL for Trader Joe's regular marshmallows, Dandies, Marshmallow Fluff, Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme and the other gelatin-free products in this report, along with Elyon's fish-gelatin marshmallows. The source of their flavorings is not disclosed, so we advise refraining from them until it is.

This verdict reflects U.S. labels and company statements checked on November 15 and 16, 2026. Recipes change and differ by market, so always read the label on the pack in your hand. If a manufacturer replaces its gelatin with a halal-slaughtered, certified source, or with a plant-based gelling agent, Halal Watch World will review its products again. We encourage marshmallow makers to disclose the source of their gelatin and flavorings and to seek halal certification for the marshmallow products they sell in the United States, so halal-conscious consumers can enjoy them with confidence.

Looking for certified products? Search Halal Watch World certified products and companies →

Credits

Author: Dr. Asma Khan, Director of Halal Education & Training, Halal Watch World.
Scholarly guidance and editing: Imam Mansoor Rafiq Umar, CEO & President, Halal Watch World.

Cover photos: Mike Mozart (Lucky Charms, Jet-Puffed, PEEPS and Rice Krispies Treats packages) and SpaceUp Houston (MoonPie), CC BY 2.0, via Flickr; PEEPS chicks: Evan-Amos, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Photos cut out, perspective-corrected and placed on a Halal Watch background. Packaging shown is from 2011 to 2015 photos and may differ from current packaging.

Sources

Company sources (accessed November 15 and 16, 2026)

  • Kraft Heinz. JET-PUFFED Marshmallows; Mini Marshmallows; Jumbo Extra Large; Stackers; Fruity-Fun Mini; Peppermint Mini; Vanilla Marshmallow Bits; seasonal shapes; and Marshmallow Creme product pages. kraftheinz.com. JET-PUFFED brand page. kraftheinz.com/jet-puffed.
  • Target. Questions and answers on the JET-PUFFED Marshmallows 12 oz and JET-PUFFED S'moreMallows 21 oz product pages (answers by the Kraft Heinz Team), and on the Lucky Charms Marshmallow Pouch 4 oz page (answers by General Mills). Questions and answers on the JET-PUFFED Marshmallow Creme 7 oz and JELL-O Instant Sugar Free Vanilla Pudding 1 oz product pages (answers by the Kraft Heinz Team). target.com.
  • Campfire Marshmallows (Doumak, Inc.). Frequently Asked Questions; Regular Marshmallows; Campfire History; History of the Marshmallow. campfiremarshmallows.com. Doumak, Inc. Company website. doumak.com.
  • Target. Good & Gather Marshmallows and Mini Marshmallows, 10 oz; Favorite Day Halloween Friends; Trees, Santa and Gingerbread Men; Halloween Ghostly Friends; Dark Chocolate with Peppermint Giant Marshmallow; White Chocolaty Coated Stirrers with Marshmallows; and Milk Chocolaty Hot Cocoa Spoon product pages. target.com.
  • Kroger. Kroger Marshmallows, 16 oz; Kroger Regular Marshmallows, 10 oz. kroger.com.
  • Walmart. Great Value Marshmallows, 10 oz; Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Covered Marshmallows (package photograph). walmart.com.
  • ALDI. Baker's Corner Marshmallows, Mini Marshmallows and Giant Marshmallows; Specially Selected Premium Peppermint, Vanilla Bean, Cinnamon Churro and Salted Caramel Marshmallows product pages. aldi.us. ALDI U.S. Help Center, "Halal Certified Products Available At ALDI." help.aldi.us.
  • Trader Joe's. Marshmallows; Mini Marshmallows; Peppermint Mini Marshmallows; Mini Maple Flavored Marshmallows; Marshmallow Eggs; Strawberry & Watermelon Marshmallows; Snowflake Marshmallows; Dark Chocolate Dipped Candy Cane Marshmallows; S'mores Clusters; Crispy Rice Bars; and Gluten Free Double Chocolate Muffins product pages; Product FAQs. traderjoes.com.
  • Whole Foods Market. 365 by Whole Foods Market Mini Marshmallows, Large Marshmallows and Organic Galaxy Marshmallow Cereal. wholefoodsmarket.com.
  • Elyon Marshmallows and Miniature Marshmallows, Natural Vanilla, U.S. retailer listings. instacart.com; hy-vee.com; randalls.com.
  • Chicago Vegan Foods. Dandies Classic Vanilla Marshmallows; Foodservice. dandies.com.
  • Stuffed Puffs. Frequently Asked Questions; All Products. stuffedpuffs.com. Mount Franklin Foods. Acquisition announcement, August 27, 2024. mountfranklinfoods.com. Retailer listings: target.com; walmart.com; jaycfoods.com; hy-vee.com.
  • Just Born, Inc. FAQs; Ingredients; Our Story. justborn.com. PEEPS product pages. peepsbrand.com.
  • Durkee-Mower, Inc. Marshmallow Fluff Nutrition Facts; FAQ; History of Marshmallow Fluff. marshmallowfluff.com. FAQ as archived April 18, 2017. Internet Archive Wayback Machine, web.archive.org.
  • General Mills. Ask General Mills, "What's the gelatin in your marshmallow pieces (marbits) made from?" ask.generalmills.com. Lucky Charms product pages. luckycharms.com. "The History of Lucky Charms," March 17, 2025. generalmills.com.
  • Post Consumer Brands. FAQ. postconsumerbrands.com. Malt-O-Meal product pages. maltomeal.com. Honey Maid S'mores and Oreo Puffs product pages. postconsumerbrands.com. Marshmallow Fruity Pebbles. postpebblescereal.com.
  • Kellanova. U.S. FAQ, "Gelatin - Products that contain." kellanovaus.com. Kellanova Away From Home, gelatin letters dated January 1, 2025 and August 11, 2026. kellanovaawayfromhome.com. Rice Krispies Treats product pages. ricekrispiestreats.com. Rice Krispies Treats manufacturing infographic. kelloggs.com. U.S. FAQ, "Vegan and Vegetarian - Ingredients."
  • MorningStar Farms (Kellanova). FAQ. morningstarfarms.com.
  • Pop-Tarts. FAQ and Frosted S'mores product page. poptarts.com. @PopTartsUS on X, July 2, 2020.
  • Mars, Incorporated. "Mars Completes Acquisition of Kellanova," December 11, 2025. mars.com.
  • Chattanooga Bakery, Inc. MoonPie Contact and FAQ; About Us; Nutrition pages. moonpie.com.
  • Little Debbie (McKee Foods). Marshmallow Pies, Banana Marshmallow Pies, Easter Marshmallow Puffs and Marshmallow Treat retailer listings: kroger.com; instacart.com; shaws.com.
  • Hostess (The J.M. Smucker Co.). Snoballs product page. hostesscakes.com. GloBalls, Holiday Sno Balls and S'mores Cupcakes retailer listings: kroger.com; vons.com.
  • Mondelēz International. Mallomars and Pinwheels product pages. snackworks.com. Mallomars SmartLabel. smartlabel.mondelez.info.
  • Conagra Brands. Swiss Miss FAQ. swissmiss.com. Swiss Miss SmartLabel ingredient descriptions, information updated April 29, 2025. smartlabel.conagra.com.
  • Ben & Jerry's. Phish Food, Phish Food Non-Dairy, PB S'more, Gimme S'more! and Marshmallow Sky flavor pages. benjerry.com. Contact Us (frequently asked questions); Allergens. benjerry.com. Ben & Jerry's UK. "Veggie-Friendly." benjerry.co.uk.

Regulatory and statistical sources (accessed November 16, 2026)

  • U.S. Code of Federal Regulations. 21 CFR 101.22, "Foods; labeling of spices, flavorings, colorings and chemical preservatives"; 21 CFR 169.175, "Vanilla extract"; 21 CFR 169.177, "Vanilla flavoring." ecfr.gov.
  • U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, National Organic Program. "Glycerides (mono and di), Handling/Processing." Technical Evaluation Report, January 27, 2015. ams.usda.gov.
  • U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, National Organic Program. "Flavors." Limited Scope Technical Report (Handling), April 11, 2023. ams.usda.gov.
  • Borregaard. "Your guide to vanilla vs. vanillin." borregaard.com (undated).

History and industry sources

  • National Confectioners Association. "Marshmallows." candyusa.com.
  • Rumm, A. "A Snack by Any Other Name: A Brief History of Marshmallows." Delaware Division of Historical and Cultural Affairs, November 15, 2023. history.delaware.gov.
  • Kennedy, P. "Who Made That Marshmallow?" The New York Times Magazine, September 14, 2012.
  • Charron, C. "Made in Indiana: Jet-Puffed Marshmallows by The Kraft Heinz Co." Indianapolis Business Journal, August 2, 2024.
  • Doumak, A. J., and Doumak, J. "Confection and process for producing the same." U.S. Patent 2,847,311, filed April 17, 1956, granted August 12, 1958.
  • Yu, D. "Hindu leader condemns Wrigley candies made with beef-sourced gelatin." ConfectioneryNews, August 22, 2017, updated August 28, 2017.
  • Gelatin Manufacturers Institute of America. Gelatin Handbook. 2012.
  • "Nabisco's Mallomars turn 100." Food Dive, November 13, 2013. "How Mondelēz keeps Mallomars a 'cultural icon' after 113 years." Food Dive, 2026.
  • Cuni-Mertz, L. "Meet the Baker: Chattanooga Bakery's Sam Campbell V." Baking Business, June 18, 2025.
  • Blakely, N. "The 80-year journey of the Rice Krispies treat." Battle Creek Enquirer, December 20, 2017.
  • Spector, D. History of the Hostess Sno Ball. Business Insider, November 19, 2012.
  • Kuhn, L. P. "Stuffed Puffs reinvents its milk chocolate marshmallow." Snack & Bakery, April 26, 2024.
  • Purdue University Extension. "Indiana Mint Oil Production." ag.purdue.edu.

Halal Watch World sources

  • Halal Watch World ingredient database, consumer product reviews.
  • Halal Watch World. HIPS 1001:2026 §1.3.2, §1.4.1.1, §2.5.17 and §2.6.2; HIPS 1003-A:2026 §5.2, §8.5, §8.6, §8.8, §8.11 and color additives.
  • Halal Watch World. Certification Methodology & Analysis Report 2023, published January 2, 2023, PDF page 48 (section "Summary," Slaughtered Animals).

Religious sources

  • Qur'an 5:3 and 6:121, Saheeh International translation. quran.com/5/3; quran.com/6/121.
  • Sahih al-Bukhari 52. sunnah.com/bukhari:52.

Screenshots of company pages, labels and documents were captured by Halal Watch World on November 16, 2026. Each caption gives the full source address. Excerpts are reproduced for commentary and reporting.

Related reading: Is Starburst Halal? · Six Products Containing Gelatin · Hidden Haram Ingredients in Food

← Back to All Articles